I’ve been thinking a lot about the kind of publicity men are getting in entertainment news these days: Tiger Woods, Jesse James, Jim Carey, John Edwards, etc. and what it means to society. Are men cheating more, or is the media just highlighting it more? And do women cheat as much, or is it just men? And why do people cheat in the first place?
My heart broke when I heard that Jesse James cheated on Sandra Bullock. After seeing her on so many awards shows and in so many interviews praising their love and his support of her it was a very tough blow. Why did he cheat? Was it too hard for him to accept such praise? Did he feel like a failure, so he figured he may as well act like one? I’ve heard of men that have never been appreciated before to such a degree find it hard to be put up on a pedestal. I remember dating a guy several years ago that thought I was beautiful and practically worshiped me. It was really hard to take because I didn’t feel that I deserved such praise. We ended up breaking up because it was just too much pressure. Is this what Jesse, Tiger, and others went through?
I’ve brought these questions up to a lot of people I know and have gotten various responses. One male friend says that men cheat because they have pressures, like women, to live up to an ideal. Men are taught that if they want to get a “quality” woman and keep her they have to be good-looking and/or charming, rich and successful. They’re also trained to always want the next bigger, better thing. This is true of most of western society and why we’re such a disposable population. Do you have the newest cell phone? Laptop? Tablet PC? Etc? This is why that metaphor exists that when men dump their wife and mother of their 3 children for their much younger secretary, they’re trading up or getting the new model.
Some of my female friends think that men are just learning to behave poorly because women let them. Most women have a fear that a man can leave them for the “newer model” at any time, so they put up with bad behavior to not be alone. To some people it’s better to have someone than to have no one and be deemed an “old maid” by society. Women in India, Nepal and most Asian nations are treated as inferior and are only worth the dowry their family pays to marry them off. Men in these nations beat and emotionally and verbally abuse their wives because the general public believes this is just “how it is.” Young girls are sold into sexual slavery and treated as animals because they have no value without a man. This is the extreme end of the spectrum, but a valuable argument I think in the psychology behind why women act as they do, even in the western world.
Or is it more of a god complex? Where famous, powerful men feel that they’re untouchable and can do whatever they want? Tiger cheated multiple times because he liked the attention and thought he couldn’t get caught and nothing bad was going to happen to him. Or maybe it was just his way of mourning his father and being rebellious about the fact that he didn’t have much of a childhood. Or maybe he is just addicted to sex and Elin wasn’t enough for him. I tend NOT to believe in sex addiction, however. Not as the sole reason for a behavior anyway. One might be able to be addicted to sex, but it’s more of the feeling one has during the act than the act itself. A man or woman becomes addicted to the feeling of being wanted physically or feeling “loved” or needed in any way.
As a woman in my mid-thirties who is afraid of marriage, these stories don’t make me feel any closer to wanting to visit the altar. My dad cheated on my mom because, in my opinion, she didn’t let him feel “manly” enough in the relationship. According to an article by James Williams I read on the blog Discovery News, Psychologist Jill Weber says that, “In my experience, what I’ve seen in my practice, is that [men] want to feel like they matter. They want to feel like they can, sort of, influence their mates and their mate’s decisions or their wife’s decisions.” My mom is an aggressive, angry woman and I’m sure this attitude took its toll on my father’s masculinity. While I am in therapy to fix my issues, I am my mother’s daughter and am afraid, in a way, that any man I marry will cheat. It has been my biggest fear in every single relationship and it of course has been the reason for the demise of those same relationships.
Another question all of this raises is whether women cheat as often as men? When was the last time you read about a woman being addicted to sex? Or cheating on her husband with multiple partners? Or getting pregnant by another man? I am not excusing women and saying these things don’t happen, just wondering if they happen as much and why or why not?
As a woman, I often feel the pressures the media puts on us to look and be a certain way. Women in magazines often have perfect bodies, hair, teeth, skin and clothes. Women in film and on TV are more often than not flawlessly beautiful with size 8 shoe and size 6 dress (if not smaller). We are taught that we can only attract a “quality” man if we are pretty, thin with big boobs, successful (but not more successful than him, we wouldn’t want him to feel unnecessary), and fun. It also helps if you have small features and are little in comparison to him.
Although I’m somewhat attractive, smart, funny, loving and would be a good mother, I am 5’8″, a size 10, have size 11 shoe, adult acne and can be described sometimes as socially awkward. I love meeting new people, but often get nervous and say some pretty odd things. I know this about myself, and accept it, but realize it doesn’t always go over so well with the Brad Pitts and Donald Trumps of the world.
The DiscoveryNews article I mentioned earlier also addresses a point made by Biological Anthropologist Dr. Helen Fisher that it’s an innate desire in animals to cheat. Only 3% of mammals, humans included, pair up to rare their young. And after a study of over 40 cultures of these couples that are married and “pairing up”, 56% of men and 34% of women stated that they were overall happy with their marriage and partner, yet still cheated. So what is the reason, if not an unhappy situation, for cheating, biologically?
Dr. Fisher believes that the brain has 3 systems for mating and reproduction, sex drive, romantic love and attachment and these systems aren’t always well-connected. Meaning that you can feel romantic love for one person, extreme attachment for another person, and really want to have sex with yet a different person. This doesn’t usually happen, though and most times people feel all three of these for the same person. This is what explains, according to Dr. Fisher, why you can be in love with more than one person at a time. However, because of our large cerebral cortex, we are able to overcome this biology to marry and not cheat. Therefore, although it is a natural desire to cheat, our brain enables us to consider the ramifications of our actions and choose whether to cheat or not.
So are my fears justified? Or is the media just trying to make us think that a lot of men are snakes and ignoring the women that behave the same way? Are we a society doomed to infidelity and insecurity? Or is there a way to overcome this and change the way men and women think and behave? Can we overcome and dominate the biological desire to be promiscuous?
Dr. Helen Fisher
How to Keep Him from Cheating
Smart Men Less Likely to Cheat Than Dumb Ones